The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.  The Mayor informed the Members that they were entitled to use the group voting system for this Committee, as set out in Schedule 10 of the LG Act 2001, as amended, with groups consisting of at least twelve members. 

It was proposed by Councillor L. Corkery and seconded by Councillor E. Dockrell and AGREED:

“That Councillor Tom O’Leary be appointed to EMRA.”

It was proposed by Councillor J. Walsh and seconded by Councillor M. McCamley and AGREED:

“That Councillor David Healy be appointed to EMRA.”

It was proposed by Councillor E. O’Brien and seconded by Councillor T. Kitt and AGREED:

“That Councillor Eimear Carbone-Mangan be appointed to EMRA.”

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED. 

It was proposed by Councillor D. Smith and seconded by Councillor J. Walsh:

“That Councillor Robert O’Donoghue be appointed to EMRA.”

It was proposed by Councillor D. Butler and seconded by Councillor F. Cooper:

“That Councillor Brigid Manton be appointed to EMRA.”

It was proposed by Councillor K. Dennison and seconded by Councillor T. Leddy:

“That Councillor T. O’Leary be appointed to EMRA.”

It was proposed by Councillor R. O’Gorman and seconded by Councillor I. Carey:

“That Councillor D. Healy be appointed to the EMRA.”

The Mayor then instructed that a roll call vote be taken and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

FOR COUNCILLOR O’DONOGHUE:           25      TWENTY FIVE

AGAINST COUNCILLOR O’DONOGHUE:             8        EIGHT

FOR: Councillors O’Brien, Eoghan; O’Callaghan, Cian; Mulville, Paul; Mulligan, Dean; Maguire, Grainne; Murphy, Tony; O’Gorman, Roderic; Carey, Ian; Whooley, Daniel; Cooper, Freddie; Manton, Brigid; Kitt, Tom; Ó Rodaigh, Seána; Walsh, John; McCamley, Mary; Boland, Cathal; Healy, David; O’Brien, Joe; Henchy, Adrian; Butler, Darragh; Mahony, Howard;  Dennehy, Brian; O’Donoghue, Robert; McDonagh, Brian; Smith, Duncan.

AGAINST: Councillors Tormey, Aoibhinn; O’Leary, Tom; Currie, Emer; Lavin, Anthony; Newman, Joe; Guerin, Jimmy; Dennison, Kieran; Leddy, Ted; Rane, Punam.

FOR COUNCILLOR MANTON:                              23      TWENTY THREE

AGAINST COUNCILLOR MANTON:            9        NINE

FOR: Councillors O’Brien, Eoghan; O’Callaghan, Cian; Mulville, Paul; Maguire, Grainne; Murphy, Tony; Carey, Ian; Whooley, Daniel; Cooper, Freddie; Manton, Brigid; Kitt, Tom; Ó Rodaigh, Seána; Walsh, John; McCamley, Mary; Boland, Cathal; Healy, David; O’Brien, Joe; Henchy, Adrian; Butler, Darragh; Mahony, Howard;  Dennehy, Brian; O’Donoghue, Robert; McDonagh, Brian; Smith, Duncan.

AGAINST: Councillors Tormey, Aoibhinn; O’Leary, Tom; Currie, Emer; Lavin, Anthony; Newman, Joe; Guerin, Jimmy; Dennison, Kieran; Leddy, Ted; Rane, Punam; Mulligan, Dean.

FOR COUNCILLOR O’LEARY:                     8        EIGHT

AGAINST COUNCILLOR O’LEARY:                       26      TWENTY SIX

FOR: Councillors Tormey, Aoibhinn; O’Leary, Tom; Currie, Emer; Lavin, Anthony; Newman, Joe; Guerin, Jimmy; Dennison, Kieran; Leddy, Ted; Rane, Punam.

AGAINST: Councillors O’Brien, Eoghan; O’Callaghan, Cian; Mulville, Paul; Burtchaell, John; Mulligan, Dean; Maguire, Grainne; Murphy, Tony; Carey, Ian; Whooley, Daniel; Cooper, Freddie; Manton, Brigid; Kitt, Tom; Ó Rodaigh, Seána; Walsh, John; McCamley, Mary; Boland, Cathal; Healy, David; O’Brien, Joe; Henchy, Adrian; Butler, Darragh; Mahony, Howard;  Dennehy, Brian; O’Donoghue, Robert; McDonagh, Brian; Smith, Duncan.

FOR COUNCILLOR HEALY:                                  24      TWENTY FOUR

AGAINST COUNCILLOR HEALY:                          6        SIX

FOR: Councillors O’Brien, Eoghan; O’Callaghan, Cian; Mulville, Paul; Maguire, Grainne; Murphy, Tony; O’Gorman, Roderic; Carey, Ian; Whooley, Daniel; Cooper, Freddie; Manton, Brigid; Kitt, Tom; Ó Rodaigh, Seána; Walsh, John; McCamley, Mary; Boland, Cathal; Healy, David; O’Brien, Joe; Henchy, Adrian; Butler, Darragh; Mahony, Howard;  Dennehy, Brian; O’Donoghue, Robert; McDonagh, Brian; Smith, Duncan.

AGAINST: Councillors Tormey, Aoibhinn; O’Leary, Tom; Lavin, Anthony; Guerin, Jimmy; Dennison, Kieran; Leddy, Ted; Rane, Punam.

The Mayor then DECLARED Councillors Robert O’Donoghue, Brigid Manton and David Healy be appointed as members of EMRA.