Minutes

Items
No. Item

FDP2/280/22

CE CH 13.1 pdf icon PDF 13 KB

It was decided to take Items 288, 289, 290, 291, 294, 295 and 296 in conjunction with this Item.

 

Item No. 280 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

Following discussion the Chief Executive’s Recommendation was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

 

For:                Twenty – Five (25)

Against:        Ten (10)

Abstain:       One (1) 

 

For:              Councillors:  Hopkins, Mulville, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Whooley, Carey, Power, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Doyle, Newman, Boland, Healy, Conroy, Butler, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.  

 

 Against:       Councillors:  Mahony, O’ Brien, Kitt, Manton, Tormey, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Guerin, Henchy.

 

 Abstain:      Councillor:  Murphy.

 

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony declared the Chief Executive’s recommendation AGREED.

 

Item No 288

Motion from Councillor Joan Hopkins, Councillor Paul Mulville: ‘Residential Care Home/Retirement Home’ and ‘Sheltered Accommodation’ AI082180

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Hopkins, Councillor P. Mulville was WITHDRAWN.

 

Item No 289

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville: Support for CE CH 13.1, Page 416, CE Report. AI081742

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor P. Mulville was WITHDRAWN.

 

Item No 290

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Part 3 Ch.13 land use zoning page 395 CE report. AI081524

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman was WITHDRAWN.

 

Item No 291

Motion from Councillor Anthony Lavin: Amend Chapter13 Land Use Zoning Objective CI Community Infrastructure to Allow Residents of Retirement Villages to Include Those Who Are Not On the Fingal Housing List. AI082126

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor A. Lavin, was proposed by Councillor A. Lavin, seconded by Councillor T. O’ Leary:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

Item No 294

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Motion to amend Caveat 19 CH. CE. 13.1. AI081728

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman was WITHDRAWN at the meeting of 3rd October, it was subsequently heard at the meeting of 4th October:

 

Minute Number FDP2/294/22 REFERS

 

Item No 295

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Amend CEs recommendation CE Ch 13.1. AI081704

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman was WITHDRAWN.

 

Item No 296

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Chapter 13 new zoning objective. AI081553

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman was WITHDRAWN.

 

FDP2/281/22

CE CH 13.2 pdf icon PDF 12 KB

Item No. 281 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/282/22

CE CH 13.4 pdf icon PDF 18 KB

Item No. 282 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/283/22

CE CH 13.5 pdf icon PDF 13 KB

Item No. 283 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/284/22

CE CH 13.6 pdf icon PDF 13 KB

It was decided to take Items 298 and 299 in conjunction with this Item.

 

Item No. 284 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

During the debate on Item No 284 The Mayor Councillor H. Mahony excused himself from the meeting and The Deputy Mayor, Councillor C. Boland presided.

 

The Mayor Councillor H. Mahony retook the chair on his return to the Chamber.

 

It was AGREED to extend the meeting to deal with this Item.

 

Following discussion the Chief Executive’s recommendation was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

 

For:                Twenty – Six (26)

Against:        Nine (9)

Abstain:        Zero (0) 

 

For:                Councillors:  Mahony, Maguire, Murphy, Carey, Power, O’ Brien, Kitt, Manton, McCamley, Tormey, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.  

 

 Against:       Councillors:  Hopkins, Mulville, Graves, Treacy, Whooley, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, Doyle, Humphreys.

 

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Chief Executive’s recommendation AGREED.

 

Item No 299

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville, Councillor Joan Hopkins: Retain Data Centres as not Permitted Within the HT (High Technology) Zoning Objective. AI082333

 

As Item No 284 had been AGREED, the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony declared the attached Motion Item 299 FALLS.

 

Item No 298

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville, Councillor Joan Hopkins: Include Data Centres as not Permitted Within the GE (General Employment) Zoning Matrix. AI082331

 

It was AGREED to DEFER this item to the next meeting 4th October.

 

Minute Number FDP2/298/22 REFERS

 

ADJOURNMENT OF MEETING

IT WAS AGREED TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 23.00 PM AND RESUME THE MEETING AT 3.00 PM TUESDAY 4TH OCTOBER 2022? 

 

Minutes of Fingal Development Plan 2023 - 2029 held on Tuesday, 4th October 2022 in the Council Chamber, Swords, at 3.00 p.m.

PRESENT? 

 

COUNCILLORS?? 

Boland, Cathal?? 

Butler, Darragh?? 

Carey, Ian?? 

Conroy, Pamela? 

Dennehy, Brian? 

Dennison, Kieran?? 

Donnelly, Angela? 

Doyle, Tania?? 

Graves, Ann?? 

Guerin, Jimmy?? 

Hanaphy, Breda?? 

Healy, David? 

Henchy, Adrian? 

Hopkins, Joan?? 

Humphreys, James?? 

Kitt, Tom?? 

Lavin, Anthony?? 

Leddy, Ted?? 

Maguire, Grainne?? 

?? 

?? 

?? 

Mahony, Howard?? 

Manton, Brigid?? 

McCamley, Mary?? 

McDonagh, Brian?? 

Mulville, Paul? 

Murphy, Tony?? 

Newman, Joe? 

O’Brien, Eoghan?? 

O’ Donoghue, Robert? 

O’Leary, Tom? 

Onwumereh, JK? 

Ó Rodaigh, Seana? 

Power, Karen?? 

Rane, Punam?? 

Shovlin, Siobhan?? 

Tormey, Aoibhinn? 

Treacy, Natalie? 

Walsh, John? 

?? 

Apologies for the inability to attend were received from Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor J. Burtchaell, Councillor D. Mulligan. 

?? 

The Mayor, Councillor Howard Mahony presided.? 

 

OFFICIALS PRESENT?? 

???? 

AnnMarie Farrelly, Chief Executive, Matthew Mc?Aleese, Director of Services/Planning & Strategic Infrastructure Department, Mary Godwin, Senior Executive Officer, Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, Stephen?Gaughran, Chief Technician,?Paul Carroll, Senior Engineer, Kevin Halpenny, Senior Parks Superintendent, Fearghal McSweeney, Administrative Officer, Sean Flahive, Senior Executive Planner, Donall O’Ceallaigh, Senior Executive Planner, Patrick Murphy, Senior Executive Technician, Sandra Hanratty, Senior Staff Officer, Mary O’Reilly, Senior Staff Officer, Elaine Gannon, Staff Officer, David Daly, Assistant Staff Officer, Linda Fanning, Clerical Officer, Louise McAuley Baker, Clerical Officer.

 

DEFERRED ITEM No 298

The attached motion in the name of Councillor P. Mulville, Councillor J. Hopkins was proposed by Councillor J. Hopkins, seconded by Councillor P. Mulville:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

Following discussion, the Motion was put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:???? 

?? 

For:                Nine (9)?? 

Against:        Twenty – Four (24)?? 

Abstain:        One (1) 

?? 

For:                Councillors:? Hopkins, Mulville, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, McCamley, Doyle, Newman.  

 

?Against:        Councillors:?Mahony,Maguire, Murphy, Carey, O’ Brien, Kitt, Manton, Ó Rodaigh, O’Leary, Lavin, Guerin, Boland, Healy, Conroy,?Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy, Rane. 

 

Abstain:        Councillors:? Power. 

 

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony declare the Motion LOST.

 

 

 

FDP2/285/22

CE CH 13.7 pdf icon PDF 18 KB

Item No. 285 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/286/22

CE CH 13.8 pdf icon PDF 16 KB

Item No. 286 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/287/22

CE CH 2.8 pdf icon PDF 17 KB

Item No. 287 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/288/22

Motion from Councillor Joan Hopkins, Councillor Paul Mulville: ‘Residential Care Home/Retirement Home’ and ‘Sheltered Accommodation’.. AI082180 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

Minute Number FDP2/280/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/289/22

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville: Support for CE CH 13.1, Page 416, CE Report. AI081742 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

Minute Number FDP2/280/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/290/22

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Part 3 Ch.13 land use zoning page 395 CE report. AI081524 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

Minute Number FDP2/280/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/291/22

Motion from Councillor Anthony Lavin: Amend Chapter13 Land Use Zoning Objective CI Community Infrastructure to Allow Residents of Retirement Villages to Include Those Who Are Not On the Fingal Housing List. AI082126 pdf icon PDF 31 KB

Minute Number FDP2/280/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/292/22

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Amend Community Infrastructure Zoning Objective. AI082222 pdf icon PDF 25 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman, was proposed by Councillor J. Newman, seconded by Councillor J. Guerin:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/293/22

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Amend community infrastructure zoning objective. AI081729 pdf icon PDF 23 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman was WITHDRAWN.

 

FDP2/294/22

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Motion to amend Caveat 19 CH. CE. 13.1. AI081728 pdf icon PDF 24 KB

Minute Number FDP2/280/22 also REFERS

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman, was proposed by Councillor J. Newman, seconded by Councillor J. Guerin:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

 

FDP2/295/22

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Amend CEs recommendation CE Ch 13.1. AI081704 pdf icon PDF 24 KB

Minute Number FDP2/280/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/296/22

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Chapter 13 new zoning objective. AI081553 pdf icon PDF 27 KB

Minute Number FDP2/280/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/297/22

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Add to Permitted in Principal category of CI zoning, subject to Caveat 19. AI081731 pdf icon PDF 26 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman, was proposed by Councillor J. Newman, seconded by Councillor P. Mulville:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

An amendment was proposed by Councillor J. Newman, seconded by Councillor J. Guerin to:

 

To Read:

Add to Permitted in Principal category of CI zoning, subject to Caveat 19

 

Motion: to add EV charging points in the Permitted in Principle category in Community Infrastructure

 

The amendment was AGREED.

 

Following discussion, the amended Motion was WITHDRAWN.

FDP2/298/22

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville, Councillor Joan Hopkins: Include Data Centres as not Permitted Within the GE (General Employment) Zoning Matrix. AI082331 pdf icon PDF 38 KB

Minute Number FDP2/284 REFERS

FDP2/299/22

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville, Councillor Joan Hopkins: Retain Data Centres as not Permitted Within the HT (High Technology) Zoning Objective. AI082333 pdf icon PDF 38 KB

Minute Number FDP2/284/22 REFERS

FDP2/300/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Daniel Whooley: Metro Rail Economic Zoning. AI082055 pdf icon PDF 24 KB

It was AGREED to DEFER Items 300, 301 and 302 until Item 623 is reached.

 

Minute Number FDP2/623/22 from meeting held on 17th October 2022 REFERS.

FDP2/301/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Daniel Whooley: Metro Rail Economic Zoning. AI082056 pdf icon PDF 24 KB

It was AGREED to DEFER Items 300, 301 and 302 until Item 623 is reached.

 

Minute Number FDP2/623/22 from meeting held on 17th October 2022 REFERS.

 

FDP2/302/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Daniel Whooley: Metro Rail Economic Zoning. AI082060 pdf icon PDF 24 KB

It was AGREED to DEFER Items 300, 301 and 302 until Item 623 is reached.

 

Minute Number FDP2/623/22 from meeting held on 17th October 2022 REFERS.

 

FDP2/303/22

CE CH 14.1 pdf icon PDF 27 KB

It was decided to take Items 310, 326 and 327 in conjunction with this Item.

 

Item No. 303 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

Item No 310

CE CH 3.9

 

Item No. 310 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

 

Item No 326

Motion from Councillor Joan Hopkins, Councillor Paul Mulville: Opposing CE CH 3.9. AI082182

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Hopkins, Councillor P. Mulville was proposed by Councillor P. Mulville, seconded by Councillor J. Hopkins:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

Item No 327

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville: Opposing CE CH 3.9. AI082085

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor P. Mulville was WITHDRAWN.

FDP2/304/22

CE CH 14.2 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

Item No. 304 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/305/22

CE CH 14.3 pdf icon PDF 19 KB

It was decided to take Items 332, 333 and 334 in conjunction with this Item.

 

Item No. 305 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

Item No 332

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley: Amend CE Recommendation re: DMSO94. AI081777

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor D. Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley was proposed by Councillor K. Power, seconded by Councillor I. Carey:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

Item No 333

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Karen Power: Data Centres. AI081990

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor K. Power was proposed by Councillor D. Healy, seconded by Councillor K. Power:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

It was AGREED that a Chief Executive Amendment would be brought back to a later meeting for the Members consideration.

 

FDP2/792/22 at meeting held on 19/10/2022 REFERS

 

 

Item No 334

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville, Councillor Joan Hopkins: Add Bullet Point to Objective DMSO94 to Allow for Oversight of the Benefits of Data Centres. AI082337

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor P. Mulville, Councillor J. Hopkins was proposed by Councillor P. Mulville, seconded by Councillor J. Hopkins:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/306/22

CE CH 14.4 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

Item No. 306 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/307/22

CE CH 14.5 pdf icon PDF 12 KB

Item No. 307 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/308/22

CE CH 3.4 pdf icon PDF 25 KB

Item No. 308 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/309/22

CE CH 3.5 pdf icon PDF 19 KB

Item No. 309 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/310/22

CE CH 3.9 pdf icon PDF 24 KB

Minute Number FDP2/303/22 REFERS

FDP2/311/22

CE CH 3.10 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

Item No. 311 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/312/22

CE CH 4.4 pdf icon PDF 21 KB

It was decided to take Item 325 in conjunction with this Item.

 

Item No. 312 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

Item No 325

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley and Councillor Pamela Conroy: Amendment. AI081810

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power, Councillor D. Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy was WITHDRAWN.

 

FDP2/313/22

CE CH 4.5 pdf icon PDF 21 KB

Item No. 313 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following discussion, Roisin Burke, Senior Planner indicated that, the Chief Executive’s Recommendation would be amended to take account of the passing of Item No 68 which stated:

 

New residential development on greenfield sites/LAP lands minimum public open space standards 12% - 15%. 15% will be the presumed minimum open space provision except in cases where the developer can demonstrate that this is not possible, in which case the 12% to 15% range will apply.

 

It was AGREED that a Chief Executive Amendment would be brought back to a later meeting for the Members consideration.

 

FDP2/791/22 at meeting held on 19th October 2022 REFERS.

FDP2/314/22

CE CH 4.6 pdf icon PDF 19 KB

It was decided to take Item 331 in conjunction with this Item.

 

Item No. 314 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

Item No 331

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor David Healy: Amendment. AI082048

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor D. Healy was proposed by Councillor K. Power, seconded by Councillor P. Conroy:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/315/22

CE CH 5.2 pdf icon PDF 19 KB

Item No. 315 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/316/22

CE OPR CH 6.3 pdf icon PDF 24 KB

Item No. 316 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/317/22

CE CH 9.9 pdf icon PDF 22 KB

It was decided to take Item 344 in conjunction with this Item.

 

Item No 344

Motion from Councillor Brian McDonagh: Amend Objective WQ05 in line with C-453-1231. AI082239

 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. McDonagh, was proposed by Councillor B. McDonagh, seconded by Councillor J. Humphreys:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

Item No 317

CE CH 9.9

 

Item No. 317 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/318/22

CE CH 9.10 pdf icon PDF 22 KB

Item No. 318 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/319/22

CE CH 9.11 pdf icon PDF 19 KB

Item No. 319 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/320/22

CE CH 9.13 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

Item No. 320 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/321/22

CE CH 11.5 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

Item No. 321 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/322/22

CE CH 9.12 pdf icon PDF 13 KB

Item No. 322 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/323/22

Motion from Councillor Siobhan Shovlin: Planning Complaints and Investigations. AI082211 pdf icon PDF 33 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor S. Shovlin, was proposed by Councillor S. Shovlin, seconded by Councillor T. O’ Leary:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/324/22

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley: Amend Objective DMSOXX. AI081771 pdf icon PDF 29 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor D. Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley was proposed by Councillor K. Power, seconded by Councillor I. Carey:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/325/22

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley and Councillor Pamela Conroy: Amendment . AI081810 pdf icon PDF 33 KB

Minute Number FDP2/312/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/326/22

Motion from Councillor Joan Hopkins, Councillor Paul Mulville: Opposing CE CH 3.9. AI082182 pdf icon PDF 36 KB

Minute Number FDP2/303/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/327/22

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville: Opposing CE CH 3.9. AI082085 pdf icon PDF 36 KB

Minute Number FDP2/303/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/328/22

Motion from Councillor Tom O'Leary: Policy on Granny Flats Increase Size to 75m2 ( currently 60m2). AI081940 pdf icon PDF 49 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

 

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

 

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

 

For:                Nineteen (19) 

Against:        Eighteen (18) 

Abstain:        Nil (0)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Manton, Tormey, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, O’Donoghue, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

 

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Carey, Power, O’ Brien, Kitt, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, Humphreys.

 

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

 

FDP2/329/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Daniel Whooley: Car Parking. AI082418 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Healy, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor K. Power, Councillor D. Whooley was WITHDRAWN.

 

FDP2/330/22

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley and Councillor Pamela Conroy: Amendment. AI081812 pdf icon PDF 39 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power, Councillor D. Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy was WITHDRAWN.

 

FDP2/331/22

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor David Healy: Amendment. AI082048 pdf icon PDF 29 KB

Minute Number FDP2/314/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/332/22

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley: Amend CE Recommendation re: DMSO94. AI081777 pdf icon PDF 29 KB

Minute Number FDP2/305/22 REFERS

FDP2/333/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Karen Power: Data Centres. AI081990 pdf icon PDF 51 KB

Minute Number FDP2/305/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/334/22

Motion from Councillor Paul Mulville, Councillor Joan Hopkins: Add Bullet Point to Objective DMSO94 to Allow for Oversight of the Benefits of Data Centres. AI082337 pdf icon PDF 54 KB

Minute Number FDP2/305/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/335/22

Motion from Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor David Healy , Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Karen Power: Amend Objective DMSO104. AI082437 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

It was AGREED to DEFER  this Item until a later meeting.

 

Minute Number FDP2/795/22 at meeting held on 19th October 2022 REFERS

 

 

FDP2/336/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy: Car-Free Neighbourhoods. AI082417 pdf icon PDF 33 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Healy, Councillor K. Power, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy was proposed by Councillor D. Healy, seconded by Councillor P. Conroy:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/337/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Karen Power: Bicycle Parking At Public Transport Stations And Stops. AI081981 pdf icon PDF 21 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor K. Power was proposed by Councillor D. Healy, seconded by Councillor P. Conroy:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

An amendment was proposed by Councillor D. Healy, seconded by Councillor P. Conroy to:

 

Amend 40% to 10 to 30%

To Read:

Bicycle Parking At Public Transport Stations And Stops

 

That the following be included in Table 14.17: Bicycle Parking Standards:

 

Rail, Metro, Light Rail stations and stops / - / sufficient to meet the anticipated demand for cycling when planned cycling and active travel infrastructure is in place. Where the anticipated demand for cycling to a metro/heavy rail/light rail station hasn't been estimated, a norm of 10 to 30% of trips to rail stations being made by bicycle will be used for the provision of bicycle parking. Bus stops on major bus routes/- / provision to meet estimated demand where space is available.

 

The amendment was AGREED.

 

Following discussion, the amended Motion was AGREED.

 

ADJOURNMENT OF MEETING

The meeting was adjourned at 6.00 p.m., and it was AGREED to recommence at 6.40 p.m.?

? 

? 

RESUMPTION OF MEETING? 

? 

The meeting was resumed at 6.40 p.m.? A roll call established a quorum of Members were present, as follows:?? 

 

PRESENT? 

 

COUNCILLORS?? 

Boland, Cathal?? 

Butler, Darragh?? 

Carey, Ian?? 

Conroy, Pamela? 

Dennehy, Brian? 

Dennison, Kieran?? 

Donnelly, Angela? 

Doyle, Tania?? 

Graves, Ann?? 

Guerin, Jimmy?? 

Hanaphy, Breda?? 

Healy, David? 

Henchy, Adrian? 

Hopkins, Joan?? 

Humphreys, James?? 

Kitt, Tom?? 

Lavin, Anthony?? 

Leddy, Ted?? 

Maguire, Grainne?? 

?? 

?? 

?? 

Mahony, Howard?? 

Manton, Brigid?? 

McCamley, Mary?? 

McDonagh, Brian?? 

Mulville, Paul? 

Murphy, Tony?? 

Newman, Joe? 

O’Brien, Eoghan?? 

O’ Donoghue, Robert? 

O’Leary, Tom? 

Onwumereh, JK? 

Ó Rodaigh, Seana? 

Power, Karen?? 

Rane, Punam?? 

Shovlin, Siobhan?? 

Tormey, Aoibhinn? 

Treacy, Natalie? 

Walsh, John? 

?? 

 

FDP2/338/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Karen Power: Bicycle Parking Standards. AI081982 pdf icon PDF 29 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor K. Power was proposed by Councillor D. Healy, seconded by Councillor I. Carey:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/339/22

Motion from Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Karen Power, Councillor David Healy: Insert New after Objective DMSO115. AI082440 pdf icon PDF 21 KB

It was AGREED to DEFER this Item until a later meeting.

 

Minute Number FDP2/796/22 at meeting held on 19th October 2022 REFERS

 

FDP2/340/22

Motion from Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Karen Power, Councillor David Healy: Insert New after Objective DMSO115. AI082444 pdf icon PDF 22 KB

It was AGREED to DEFER this Item until a later meeting.

 

Minute Number FDP2/797/22 at meeting held on 19th October 2022 REFERS

 

FDP2/341/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Karen Power: Parking Norms. AI081979 pdf icon PDF 37 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor K. Power was proposed by Councillor D. Healy, seconded by Councillor I. Carey:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/342/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Daniel Whooley, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Karen Power: Zone 1 Parking Maximums. AI081980 pdf icon PDF 21 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor, K. Power was WITHDRAWN.

 

FDP2/343/22

Motion from Councillor David Healy, Councillor Pamela Conroy, Councillor Ian Carey, Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Daniel Whooley: Car Parking for Shared Cars. AI082423 pdf icon PDF 20 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Healy, Councillor P. Conroy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor K. Power, Councillor D. Whooley was WITHDRAWN.

 

FDP2/344/22

Motion from Councillor Brian McDonagh: Amend Objective WQ05 in line with C-453-1231. AI082239 pdf icon PDF 53 KB

Minute Number FDP2/317/22 REFERS

 

FDP2/345/22

Motion from Councillor Anthony Lavin: Chapter 11: Infrastructure and Utilities Objective DMSO225 – Applications for Telecommunications Structures. AI082131 pdf icon PDF 47 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor A. Lavin, was proposed by Councillor A. Lavin, seconded by Councillor T. O’ Leary:                         

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

 

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

 

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

 

For:                Eighteen (18) 

Against:        Eighteen (18) 

Abstain:       One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Mahony, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Carey, Power, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Guerin, Boland, Healy, Conroy, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

 

?Against:       Councillors:? Hopkins, Mulville, Maguire, Murphy, O’ Brien, Kitt, Manton, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Tormey, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys.

 

Abstain:       Councillors:? Newman.

 

On the casting vote of the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony voted for the motion. 

 

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony declared the Motion PASSED.

 

FDP2/346/22

Motion from Councillor Joan Hopkins, Councillor Paul Mulville: Telecoms Masts. AI082172 pdf icon PDF 37 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Hopkins, Councillor P. Mulville was proposed by Councillor P. Mulville, seconded by Councillor J. Hopkins:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/347/22

CE NTA CH 6.2 pdf icon PDF 13 KB

Item No. 347 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/348/22

CE NTA CH 6.4 pdf icon PDF 13 KB

Item No. 348 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/349/22

CE EMRA CH 7.1 pdf icon PDF 14 KB

Item No. 349 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/350/22

CE APP 5.1 pdf icon PDF 25 KB

Item No. 350 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

 

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

 

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

 

FDP2/351/22

Motion from Councillor Joe Newman: Swords ACA Motion. AI081055 pdf icon PDF 28 KB

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman, was proposed by Councillor J. Newman, seconded by Councillor A. Graves:

 

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

 

It was AGREED that a Chief Executive Amendment would be brought back to a later meeting for the Members consideration.

 

FDP2/793/22 at meeting held on 19/10/2022 REFERS.

 

ADJOURNMENT OF MEETING

IT WAS AGREED TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 8.05 PM AND RESUME THE MEETING AT 3.00 PM FRIDAY 7TH OCTOBER 2022 

 

 

All Rights Reserved © Fingal County Council