?? 

PRESENT? 

Apologies were received from Councillor J. Burtchaell, Councillor D. Mulligan, Councillor A. Tormey. 

?? 

The Mayor, Councillor Howard Mahony presided.? 

OFFICIALS PRESENT??? 

???? 

AnnMarie Farrelly, Chief Executive, Matthew Mc?Aleese, Director of Services/Planning & Strategic Infrastructure Department, John Quinlivan, Director of Services/Economic, Enterprise, Culture and Tourism Department, Mary Godwin, Senior Executive Officer, Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, Stephen?Gaughran, Chief Technician,?Paul Carroll, Senior Engineer, Kevin Halpenny, Senior Parks Superintendent, Fearghal McSweeney, Administrative Officer, Sean Flahive, Senior Executive Planner, Donall O’Ceallaigh, Senior Executive Planner, Patrick Murphy, Senior Executive Technician, Sandra Hanratty, Senior Staff Officer, Mary O’Reilly, Senior Staff Officer, Elaine Gannon, Staff Officer, David Daly, Assistant Staff Officer, Linda Fanning, Clerical Officer, Louise McAuley Baker, Clerical Officer.

Matthew Mc Aleese, Director of Services gave a presentation to the Members in respect of this stage of the Development Plan.

Matthew Mc Aleese, Director of Services then provided an overview of the conclusions reached in the Fingal Economic and Employment Land Use Study undertaken by KPMG on behalf of Fingal County Council.

He stated that he understood that an explanatory note has been prepared by KPMG and this has been widely circulated by a 3rd party consultant unrelated to KPMG to the Members, with a cover letter that refers to a note as being a review and update of the earlier study just referenced.

Matthew Mc Aleese confirmed to the Members that no such report or update to the original study was commissioned by Fingal County Council.  The report handed in to Fingal County Council, as it referenced the Fingal Development Plan has been returned as it was received outside the statutory timelines.

Clarification was sought by Fingal County Council from KPMG and Matthew Mc Aleese then read a letter into the record in response from KPMG as follows:

I am writing to you in respect of an explanatory note prepared by KPMG Future Analytics for a client’s internal digestion, at their request, relating to the Fingal Economic and Employment Land Use Study (the “Study”) which KPMG had previously prepared on behalf of Fingal County Council.

I feel it is important to clarify some key points in this respect:

·         I have learned in recent days that this note has been widely circulated by a third party consultant (unrelated to KPMG) to the Members of Fingal County Council and others, and that this individual’s cover letter refers to the note as being a “review and update” of our earlier Study.

·         I am eager to clarify that the note is categorically not a review nor an update of the Fingal Economic and Employment Land Use Study. KPMG reaffirms the research and findings of the original Study, and in no way seeks to undermine, discredit or cause uncertainty in respect of that report’s research and findings. 

·         The note which has been circulated was not intended for publication or wider circulation in this manner. It was prepared for information purposes only for one client. KPMG were not aware of its wider circulation until highlighted by yourselves late last week. Indeed we would not have permitted its use in this manner had it been requested.

·         The note is a high-level, general commentary on a small and selective/non exhaustive number of items on the matter of how employment land use for Fingal could or may be interpreted. 1 This report was publicly available as part of the Development Plan process

·         This is in contrast to the comprehensive evidence-based Fingal Economic and Employment Land Use Study that was published as a supplementary report to the Draft Fingal County Development Plan 2023-2029. It is important that the note is not therefore seen as a complete research exercise or, critically, as a “review” or “update” to our original Study on Fingal County Council’s behalf.

I confirm that we have spoken with the other client in this instance, and with the third party consultant who widely circulated our client note and have raised our objections and concerns as to the use of our note in this manner.

We regret any confusion or difficulty which the wide circulation (by others) of a note, written by KPMG solely for a client’s own consideration, may give rise to. Should there be any further clarifying action or steps required in this respect following your consideration of the above, please do not hesitate to contact me. 

Michele Connolly

Partner, KPMG

Due to issues with the webcast the meeting was adjourned for 5 minutes, the meeting resumed at 16.13pm.

Item No. 352 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, gave an overview presentation on Sheet 2 - Fingal North.

It was decided to take Items 353, 361 and 362 together.

Item No 361

Motion from Councillor Grainne Maguire: Appendix A -CE OPR SH 2.1. AI082013

The attached motion in the name of Councillor G. Maguire, was proposed by Councillor G. Maguire, seconded by Councillor T. Murphy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty – Three (23) 

Against:        Thirteen (13) 

Abstain:        Zero (0)

For:                Councillors:? Mahony, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Power, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Healy, Conroy,McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Dennison.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

Item No 362

Motion from Councillor Tony Murphy: Courtlough. AI081814

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy, was proposed by Councillor T. Murphy, seconded by Councillor G. Maguire:

It was AGREED to take the same vote as Item 361 on this Motion.

For:                Twenty – Three (23) 

Against:        Thirteen (13) 

Abstain:        Zero (0)

For:                Councillors:? Mahony, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Power, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Healy, Conroy,McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Dennison.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

Item No 353

CE OPR SH 2.1

Item No. 353 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

It was noted that as a result of Item 361 and 362 being passed, Item 353 FALLS.

Item No. 354 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor A. Henchy, was proposed by Councillor A. Henchy, seconded by Councillor E. O’ Brien:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power, Councillor D.  Healy, Councillor I. Carey, Councillor D. Whooley, Councillor P. Conroy was proposed by Councillor K. Power, seconded by Councillor I. Carey:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty (20)

Against:        Seventeen (17) 

Abstain:        Zero (0)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Whooley, Carey, Power, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, O’Leary, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Healy, Conroy, Dennehy, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Maguire, Murphy, O’ Brien, Kitt, Manton, McCamley, Shovlin, Lavin, Boland, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, McDonagh, Dennison.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Newman, was proposed by Councillor J. Newman, seconded by Councillor J. Guerin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty (20)

Against:        Fifteen (15) 

Abstain:        Two (2)

For:                Councillors:? Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Onwumereh, Dennehy, Leddy, Rane

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Power, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Healy, Conroy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison.

Abstain:        Councillors:?O’Brien, Butler.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

The meeting was adjourned at 5.55 p.m., and it was AGREED to recommence at 6.40 p.m.?  

RESUMPTION OF MEETING 

? 

The meeting was resumed at 6.44 p.m.? A roll call established a quorum of Members were present, as follows:?? 

?? 

PRESENT? 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Guerin, was proposed by Councillor J. Guerin, seconded by Councillor J. Newman:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:                Two (2)

Against:        Thirty (30) 

Abstain:        Five (5)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Donnelly, Guerin.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Hanaphy, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Whooley, Carey, Power, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Boland, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison.

Abstain:        Councillors:?  Graves, Doyle, Newman, Leddy, Rane.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Guerin was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor G. Maguire, was proposed by Councillor G. Maguire, seconded by Councillor T. Murphy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED and following a discussion the Motion was WITHDRAWN.

Minute Number FDP2/353/22 REFERS

Minute Number FDP2/353/22 REFERS

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy, was proposed by Councillor T. Murphy, seconded by Councillor G. Maguire:

Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, advised the Members of a correction to the Report on this Item as follows:

C 42.4 hectares (104.7 acres)

be amended to

17 Hectares (42 acres)

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:                Seven (7)

Against:        Twenty – Six (26) 

Abstain:        Three (3)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Graves, Maguire, Murphy, O’Leary, Doyle, Guerin, Boland.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Treacy, Whooley, Carey, Power, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Shovlin, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy.

Abstain:        Councillors:?   Lavin, Newman, Rane.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy was WITHDRAWN.

Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, gave an overview presentation on Sheet 3 – Fingal Central.

Councillor C. Boland read the following statement into the record:

Mayor

I wish to make a personnel statement in respect of

Map Sheet 3

While I have no Conflict of interests, I have had in the past a business relationship with property owners of lands in the Ballymadun Area.

While these Business Relationships are long passed, I intend in the interest of the integrity of the Plan to absent myself from participation in the proceedings in respect of the general area of Ballymadun.

It was decided to take Items 389, 390 and 391 in conjunction with Item 365.

Item No 389

Motion from Councillor Brigid Manton: Extract From Dev Plan - Appendix A Chief Executive's Report Sheet 3 (2). AI081726

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Manton, was proposed by Councillor B. Manton, seconded by Councillor T. Kitt:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED and following a discussion the Motion was AGREED.

Item No 390

Motion from Councillor Brigid Manton: Extract From Dev Plan - Appendix A Chief Executive's Report Sheet 3(3). AI081727

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Manton, was proposed by Councillor B. Manton, seconded by Councillor E. O’ Brien:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty – Six (26) 

Against:       Eleven (11)  

Abstain:        Nil (0)

For:                Councillors:? Mahony, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Carey, Power, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

Item No 391

Motion from Councillor Brigid Manton: Extract From Development Plan - Appendix A Chief Executive's Report Sheet 3(1). AI081863

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Manton, was proposed by Councillor B. Manton, seconded by Councillor E. O’ Brien:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty – Nine (29) 

Against:       Eight (8)       

Abstain:        Nil (0)

For:                Councillors:? Mahony, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Carey, Power, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Healy, Conroy.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

Item No 365

CE OPR SH 3.1

It was noted that as a result of Item 389, 390 and 391 being passed, Item No 365 FALLS.

It was decided to take Item No 392 in conjunction with this Item.

Item No 392

Motion from Councillor Ann Graves: Chief Executive’s Recommendation: CE SH 3.1: Amend Local Objective 36. AI081755

The attached motion in the name of Councillor A. Graves, was proposed by Councillor A. Graves, seconded by Councillor N. Treacy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED and following a discussion the Motion was AGREED.

Item No 366

CE SH 3.1

It was noted that as a result of Item 392 being passed, Item 366 FALLS.

The meeting was adjourned at 9.00 p.m., and it was AGREED to recommence at 9.10 p. m. 

RESUMPTION OF MEETING 

? 

The meeting was resumed at 9.10 p.m.? A roll call established a quorum of Members were present, as follows:?? 

PRESENT 

Item No. 367 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Butler, Councillor B. Dennehy was proposed by Councillor D. Butler, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

An amendment was proposed by Councillor D. Butler, seconded by Councillor B. Dennehy to:

Amendment to Motion 368 to reduce the Map as per the attached:

Ballymadun, Garristown

The amendment was AGREED.

Following discussion the Amended Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Thirteen (13) 

Against:       Twenty – One (21) 

Abstain:        Two (2)

For:                Councillors:? Maguire, Murphy,O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, O’Donoghue.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Whooley, Carey, Power, Walsh, McCamley, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Healy, Conroy, McDonagh, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Newman, Rane.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the amended Motion LOST.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

Councillor C. Boland withdrew from the Chamber for the duration of this Item.

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, was proposed by Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, seconded by Councillor J. Walsh:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:                Twenty – One (21) 

Against:       Fourteen (14)

Abstain:        Nil (0)

? 

For:                Councillors:?Mulville, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Murphy, Carey, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Dennehy, O’Donoghue, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Maguire, Whooley, Power, Walsh, McCamley, Shovlin, Healy, Conroy, Butler, McDonagh, Humphreys, Dennison.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty – Four (24)

Against:       Eleven (11)

Abstain:        One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:?Mahony, Mulville, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Murphy, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, O’Donoghue, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Hopkins, Maguire, Whooley, Carey, Power, Walsh, McCamley, Healy, Conroy, McDonagh, Humphreys.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Newman.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy was WITHDRAWN.

It was decided to take Items 373, 374 and 375 together.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor C. Boland, was proposed by Councillor C. Boland, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty (20) 

Against:       Fifteen (15)

Abstain:        One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:?Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, Leddy.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Power, Walsh, McCamley, Shovlin, Healy, Conroy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Rane.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

At this point Councillor J. Guerin expressed his condolences to the people of Creeslough, Co. Donegal after news of an explosion at a petrol station in the area.

Item No 374

Motion from Councillor Cathal Boland: Extend LAP Boundary Oldtown. AI082362

The attached motion in the name of Councillor C. Boland was WITHDRAWN

Item No 375

Motion from Councillor Cathal Boland: Rezone Lands Contained In Area Of Additional Oldtown LAP Lands. AI082378

The attached motion in the name of Councillor C. Boland, was proposed by Councillor C. Boland, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                 Nineteen (19) 

Against:          Fourteen (14) 

Abstain:         Two (02) 

?? 

For:              Councillors:  Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Carey, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Doyle, Guerin, Boland, Conroy, Henchy, Onwumereh, Dennehy, Rane.

Against:        Councillors:Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Power, Walsh,McCamley, Shovlin, Lavin, Healy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison.

Abstain:        Councillors: Butler, Leddy

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

Minute Number FDP2/373/22 REFERS

Minute Number FDP2/373/22 REFERS

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Manton, was proposed by Councillor B. Manton, seconded by Councillor T. Kitt:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following discussion, the Motion was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor A. Graves, was proposed by Councillor A. Graves, seconded by Councillor B. Hanaphy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

It was agreed to extend the meeting at this time to finish this motion.

An amendment was proposed by Councillor A. Graves, seconded by Councillor B. McDonagh to:

To Remove the words “at little Moo Moos” and replace with “on the site outlined”

To Read:

Childcare Facility in the Greenbelt

That the GB land (outland in red for identification purposes) and is the land of the farm house dwelling residence and outbuildings of the operator, have a specific objective attached 'To provide for the continuing provision of Childcare Facilities and education centre on the site outlined

The amendment was AGREED.

Following discussion, the amended Motion was AGREED.

IT WAS AGREED TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 11.10 PM AND RESUME THE MEETING AT 3.00 PM TUESDAY 11^TH OCTOBER 2022? 

PRESENT? 

Apologies were received from Councillor J. Burtchaell, Councillor A. Tormey. 

?? 

The Mayor, Councillor Howard Mahony presided.? 

OFFICIALS PRESENT??? 

???? 

AnnMarie Farrelly, Chief Executive, Matthew Mc?Aleese, Director of Services/Planning & Strategic Infrastructure Department, John Quinlivan, Director of Services/Economic, Enterprise, Culture and Tourism Department, Mary Godwin, Senior Executive Officer, Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, Fionnuala May, County Architect, Stephen?Gaughran, Chief Technician,?Paul Carroll, Senior Engineer, Kevin Halpenny, Senior Parks Superintendent, Fearghal McSweeney, Administrative Officer, Sean Flahive, Senior Executive Planner, Donall O’Ceallaigh, Senior Executive Planner, Patricia Cadogan, Senior Executive Planner, Patrick Murphy, Senior Executive Technician, Sandra Hanratty, Senior Staff Officer, Mary O’Reilly, Senior Staff Officer, Elaine Gannon, Staff Officer, David Daly, Assistant Staff Officer, Linda Fanning, Clerical Officer, Louise McAuley Baker, Clerical Officer.

Following a discussion, it was AGREED to postpone the Balbriggan/Swords ACM on Thursday 13^th October and to reconvene a Development Plan meeting that day from 2pm to 11pm.

A further discussion was held in respect of Legal Advice given by the Law Agent, Matthew Mc Aleese, Director of Services, set out the Legal Advice to the Members.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Mulligan, was proposed by Councillor D. Mulligan, seconded by Councillor P. Mulville:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty- Seven (27)

Against:        Six (6) 

Abstain:        Four (4)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Mulville, Mulligan, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Murphy, Whooley, Carey, Power, O’ Brien, Kitt, Manton, Ó Rodaigh, O’Leary, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, McDonagh, Humphreys, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, McCamley, O’Donoghue, Dennison, Leddy.

Abstain:        Councillors:? Maguire, Walsh, Lavin, Dennehy.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor T. O’ Leary:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty- Nine (29)

Against:        Seven (7) 

Abstain:        One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Mahony, Mulville, Mulligan, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Carey, O’ Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Hopkins, Whooley, Power, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Humphreys.

Abstain:        Councillors:? Healy.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

It was decided to take Item 382 in conjunction with this Item.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy, was proposed by Councillor T. Murphy, seconded by Councillor G. Maguire:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following discussion, the Motion was WITHDRAWN.

Item No 382

Motion from Councillor Tony Murphy: Belinstown. AI081983

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy, was proposed by Councillor T. Murphy, seconded by Councillor G. Maguire:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following discussion, the Motion was AGREED.

Minute Number FDP2/381/22 REFERS

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Kitt, Councillor JK Onwumereh, was proposed by Councillor T. Kitt, seconded by Councillor JK Onwumereh:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:                Twelve (12)

Against:        Twenty – One (21) 

Abstain:        Three (3)

For:                Councillors:? Mahony, Murphy, O’ Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Lavin, Guerin, Henchy, Onwumereh, Dennehy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Hopkins, Mulville, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Whooley, Carey, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Shovlin, Doyle, Newman, Boland, Healy, Conroy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Dennison

Abstain:        Councillors:? Mulligan, Butler, Leddy. 

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor I. Carey, was proposed by Councillor I. Carey, seconded by Councillor P. Conroy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

An amendment was proposed by Councillor I. Carey, seconded by Councillor D. Whooley to:

Amend my motion 384 to zone the shaded are as RV from RU.

The amendment was AGREED.

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Amended Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:                Twenty – Seven (27)

Against:       Ten (10)       

Abstain:        Zero (0)

For:                Councillors:?Mulligan, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Murphy, Whooley, Carey, Power, O’Brien, Kitt, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Maguire, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the amended Motion PASSED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Butler was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor JK Onwumereh, was proposed by Councillor JK Onwumereh, seconded by Councillor T. Kitt:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Motion was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor JK Onwumereh was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor JK Onwumereh was WITHDRAWN.

The meeting was adjourned at 6.05 p.m., and it was AGREED to recommence at 6.35 p.m.? 

? 

? 

RESUMPTION OF MEETING? 

? 

The meeting was resumed at 6.35 p.m.? A roll call established a quorum of Members were present, as follows:?? 

PRESENT? 

Minute Number FDP2/365/22 REFERS

Minute Number FDP2/365/22 REFERS

Minute Number FDP2/365/22 REFERS

Minute Number FDP2/366/22 REFERS

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Butler was proposed by Councillor D. Butler, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:                Fifteen (15)

Against:       Twenty – Three (23)          

Abstain:        Zero (0)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Maguire, Murphy, O’Brien, Manton, Tormey, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, Leddy.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Mulligan, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Whooley, Carey, Power, Kitt, Ó Rodaigh, McCamley, Doyle, Newman, Healy, Conroy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison, Rane.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, gave an overview presentation on Sheet 4 - Balbriggan.

Item No. 394 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

It was decided to take Item 400 in conjunction with this Item.

Item No 400

Motion from Councillor Grainne Maguire: Map Sheet 4 Balbriggan. AI082004

The attached motion in the name of Councillor G. Maguire, was proposed by Councillor G. Maguire, seconded by Councillor T. Murphy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

Item No 395

CE SH 4.2

Item No. 395 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor G. Maguire was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor T. Kitt:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:                Ten (10)

Against:       Twenty – Six (26)   

Abstain:        Two (2)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Mahony, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Guerin, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy.

?Against:        Councillors:? Hopkins, Mulville, Mulligan, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Treacy, Maguire, Whooley, Carey, Power, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Tormey, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Healy, Conroy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

Abstain:        Councillors:? Murphy, Boland. 

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

It was decided to take Item 399 in conjunction with this Item.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

Item No 399

Motion from Councillor Tom O'Leary: Realign Indicative Route Of The Proposed Balbriggan Ring Road (R122 To R123 Via Flemington). AI081946

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

Minute Number FDP2/398/22 REFERS

Minute Number FDP2/395/22 REFERS

It was decided to take Item 402 in conjunction with this Item.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor S. O’ Rodaigh, was proposed by Councillor S. O’ Rodaigh, seconded by Councillor E. O’ Brien:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

Item No 402

Motion from Councillor Tony Murphy: Church Street Balbriggan. AI081733

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy was WITHDRAWN.

Minute number FDP2/401/22 REFERS

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy, was proposed by Councillor T. Murphy, seconded by Councillor G. Maguire:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:             Four (4)                    

Against:       Thirty – Three (33)

Abstain:        Two (2)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Maguire, Murphy, O’Leary, Guerin.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Mulligan, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Whooley, Carey, Power, O’Brien, Kitt, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Tormey, Shovlin, Doyle, Newman, Boland, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

Abstain:        Councillors:? Manton, Lavin.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor G. Maguire, was proposed by Councillor G. Maguire, seconded by Councillor T. Murphy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Tormey:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy, was proposed by Councillor T. Murphy, seconded by Councillor J. Guerin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:             Fifteen (15)             

Against:       Twenty – One (21) 

Abstain:        One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Murphy, Manton, O’Leary, Shovlin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Power, O’Brien, Kitt, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Tormey, Lavin, Healy, Conroy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Maguire. 

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

? 

The meeting was adjourned at 8.40 p.m., and it was AGREED to recommence at 8.50 p.m.? 

RESUMPTION OF MEETING?

? 

The meeting was resumed at 8.50 p.m.? A roll call established a quorum of Members were present, as follows:?? 

PRESENT? 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy, was proposed by Councillor T. Murphy, seconded by Councillor G. Maguire:                         

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:             Eighteen (18)          

Against:       Eighteen (18)          

Abstain:        One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Manton, Tormey, O’ Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Power, O’ Brien, Kitt, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Onwumereh, Dennehy, McDonagh, Humphreys.

Abstain:        Councillors:  O’ Donoghue.

On the casting vote of the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony voted against the motion. 

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony declared the Motion LOST.