Councillor B. Dennehy declared a Conflict of Interest in respect of Item No 463, he is related to the landowner through marriage.

Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, gave an overview presentation on Sheet 5 - Skerries.

It was decided to take Item 433 in conjunction with this Item.

Item No 433

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Seána Ó Rodaigh: Amendment. AI082053

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power, Councillor S.  Ó’ Rodaigh was proposed by Councillor K. Power, seconded by Councillor C. Boland and Councillor Ó Rodaigh:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:             Twenty- Three (23)

Against:       Eleven (11)  

Abstain:        Three (3)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Carey, Power, O’Brien, Manton, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, O’Leary, Lavin, Guerin, Conroy, Henchy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Mulville, Whooley, Kitt, Shovlin, Doyle, Newman, Boland, Healy, Onwumereh, Dennison.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Tormey, Butler, Dennehy.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

Item No 410

CE SH 5.1

It was noted that as a result of Item 433 being passed, Item 410 FALLS.

It was decided to take Items 432 and 434 in conjunction with this Item.

Item No 432

Motion from Councillor Karen Power, Councillor Seána Ó Rodaigh: Amendment. AI082057

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power, Councillor S. Ó’ Rodaigh was proposed by Councillor K. Power, seconded by Councillor P. Conroy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

An amendment was proposed by Councillor B. McDonagh, seconded by Councillor P. Mulville to:

DELETE 

“And to facilitate a guest house which would be ancillary to the use as a main residence.” 

To Read:

Amend: Remove Local Objective 6 as follows: 

6 Provide and facilitate the development of "glamping" accommodation allowing for a permanent structure in an associated guest house and a service building.’ 

Provide and facilitate the development of ‘glamping’ accommodation with an ancillary service building.  

The amendment was AGREED.

Following discussion, the amended Motion was AGREED.

Item No 434

Motion from Councillor Karen Power: Access Road at Holmpatrick. AI082218

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power was proposed by Councillor K. Power, seconded by Councillor D. Whooley:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

Item No 411

CE SH 5.2

It was noted that as a result of Item 432 being passed, Item 411 FALLS.

Item No. 412 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

Item No. 413 was proposed by Councillor H. Mahony, seconded by Councillor D. Whooley:

The attached Chief Executive’s Recommendation, which had been circulated was CONSIDERED.

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

An amendment was submitted by Councillor T. O’ Leary

The amendment was ruled OUT OF ORDER.

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power, was proposed by Councillor K. Power, seconded by Councillor D. Whooley:

It was agreed to extend the meeting to deal with this Item.

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor S. Ó’ Rodaigh was WITHDRAWN.

IT WAS AGREED TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 23.05 PM AND RESUME THE MEETING AT 3.00 PM WEDNESDAY 12^TH OCTOBER 2022 

PRESENT? 

Apologies for the inability to attend were received from Councillor J. Burtchaell, Councillor D. Mulligan, Councillor A. Tormey?and Councillor JK. Onwumereh is unable to attend until 6.30 PM. 

The Mayor, Councillor Howard Mahony presided.? 

?? 

OFFICIALS PRESENT???

AnnMarie Farrelly, Chief Executive, Matthew Mc?Aleese, Director of Services/Planning & Strategic Infrastructure Department, Robert Burns, Director of Services/Housing Department, Mary Godwin, Senior Executive Officer, Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, Stephen?Gaughran, Chief Technician,?Paul Carroll, Senior Engineer, Kevin Halpenny, Senior Parks Superintendent, Fearghal McSweeney, Administrative Officer, Sean Flahive, Senior Executive Planner, Donall O’Ceallaigh, Senior Executive Planner, Patricia Cadogan, Senior Executive Planner, Patrick Murphy, Senior Executive Technician, Sandra Hanratty, Senior Staff Officer, Mary O’Reilly, Senior Staff Officer, Elaine Gannon, Staff Officer, David Daly, Assistant Staff Officer, Linda Fanning, Clerical Officer, Louise McAuley Baker, Clerical Officer.

Councillor C. Boland declared he would be withdrawing from the following Items:

Item No 442

Item No 443

Item No 444

Item No 447

Item No 448

Item No 476

Councillor K. Power declared she would be withdrawing from Item 417

Councillor B. Dennehy declared a Conflict of Interest in respect of Item No 463

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor P. Rane:

Councillor K. Power withdrew from the Chamber for the duration of this Item.

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

An amendment was submitted by Councillor T. O’ Leary

The amendment was ruled OUT OF ORDER.

A subsequent amendment was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor C. Boland:

Amended map submitted with a smaller outline

The amendment was AGREED.

Following discussion the Amended Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:             Seventeen (17)

Against:       Fourteen (14)

Abstain:      Nil (0)

?? 

For:             Councillors: Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Manton, O’Leary, Lavin, Doyle, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Dennehy, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

Against:       Councillors:Mahony, Mulville, Carey, O’Brien, Kitt, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Newman, Healy, Conroy, Butler, McDonagh, O’Donoghue.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the amended Motion PASSED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor S. Ó’ Rodaigh, was proposed by Councillor S. Ó’ Rodaigh, seconded by Councillor B. McDonagh:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED and following a discussion the Motion was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor P. Rane:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:             Twenty – Three (23)          

Against:       Twelve (12) 

Abstain:        One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, Power, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, Ó Rodaigh, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Dennehy, O’Donoghue, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

 ?Against:       Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Walsh, McCamley, Healy, Conroy, Butler, McDonagh, Humphreys.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Newman.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor P. Rane:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

An amendment was submitted by Councillor T. O’ Leary

The amendment was ruled OUT OF ORDER.

A further amendment was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor P. Rane to:

Zone CI Community Infrastructure School Site (add word site)  

This Council resolves that the lands on the attached map, be zoned from “GB” - to “CI” – Community Infrastructure. 

Attached a smaller map reducing the area in the original motion and a change in the description or intent of the motion. 

Nursing Home Removed 

The amendment was AGREED.

Following discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

Minute Number FDP2/411/22 REFERS.

Minute Number FDP2/410/22 REFERS.

Minute Number FDP2/411/22 REFERS.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor K. Power was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, was proposed by Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, seconded by Councillor S. Ó Rodaigh:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:             Nineteen (19)         

Against:       Fifteen (15) 

Abstain:        One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:?Graves, Treacy, Murphy, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, Ó Rodaigh, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Dennehy, O’Donoghue, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

?Against:       Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Hanaphy, Maguire, Whooley, Carey, Power, Walsh, McCamley, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, McDonagh, Humphreys.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Donnelly.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:             Five (5)         

Against:       Twenty- Six (26)     

Abstain:        Five (5)

? 

For:                Councillors:?O’Brien, O’Leary, Shovlin, Lavin, Boland.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Whooley, Carey, Power, Kitt, Manton, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Doyle, Newman, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Murphy, Guerin, Dennehy, Leddy, Rane.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

Roisin Burke, Senior Planner, gave an overview presentation on Sheet 6 – Lusk/Rush.

It was decided to take Items 445 and 453 together.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy, was proposed by Councillor T. Murphy, seconded by Councillor G. Maguire:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

Item No 453

Motion from Councillor Tony Murphy: Lusk Quickpenny. AI081732

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. Murphy, was proposed by Councillor T. Murphy, seconded by Councillor G. Maguire:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, was proposed by Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, seconded by Councillor B. McDonagh:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

Councillor C. Boland declared a conflict of interest with this Item and withdrew from the Chamber.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED and following a discussion the Motion was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor R. O’ Donoghue was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Guerin, was proposed by Councillor J. Guerin, seconded by Councillor J. Newman:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:             Eight (8)       

Against:       Twenty- One (21)   

Abstain:        Six (6)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Murphy, O’Brien, Manton, O’Leary, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland.  

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Power, Kitt, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Shovlin, Lavin, Healy, Conroy, Henchy, Butler, Dennehy, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Dennison, Leddy.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Rane.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

The meeting was adjourned at 6.25 p.m., and it was AGREED to recommence at 6.55 p.m.? 

RESUMPTION OF MEETING 

? 

The meeting was resumed at 6.55 p.m.? A roll call established a quorum of Members were present, as follows:?? 

PRESENT? 

The attached motion in the name of Councillor R. O’ Donoghue was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor P. Rane:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED and following a discussion the Motion was WITHDRAWN.

Minute Number FDP2/445/22 REFERS.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor T. O’ Leary, was proposed by Councillor T. O’ Leary, seconded by Councillor A. Lavin:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

Following discussion the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows: 

For:             Six (6)

Against:       Twenty- Eight (28) 

Abstain:        Three (3)

? 

For:                Councillors:? Murphy, O’Leary, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, Dennehy.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Mulligan, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Whooley, Carey, Power, O’Brien, Kitt, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Newman, Healy, Conroy, Butler, Onwumereh, McDonagh, O’Donoghue, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

Abstain:        Councillors:  Manton, Lavin, Doyle.

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion LOST.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Butler, Councillor B. Dennehy was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor D. Butler, Councillor B. Dennehy was WITHDRAWN.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor A. Henchy, was proposed by Councillor A. Henchy, seconded by Councillor T. Kitt:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

It was decided to take Items 459, 467 and 468 together.

Item No 467

Motion from Councillor Robert O'Donoghue: Map Sheet 6: Retention Of School Symbol Between Golden Ridge And Kenure Woods, Rush Hands Lane, Rush. AI082002

The attached motion in the name of Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, was proposed by Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, seconded by Councillor J. Walsh:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Motion was AGREED.

Item No 468

Motion from Councillor Brian Dennehy: ‘Proposed School Symbol’ on the Lands at Golden Ridge, Skerries Road, Rush. AI082136

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor D. Butler:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Motion was AGREED.

Item No 459

CE SH 6B.1

It was noted that as a result of Items 467 and 468 being passed, Item 459 FALLS.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy was WITHDRAWN.

Councillor J. Walsh declared a conflict of interest with this Item as he is the Chairperson of the School Board where one of the parties is employed.

Councillor J. Walsh withdrew from the Chamber for the duration of this Item.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor R. O’ Donoghue:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

An amendment was submitted by Councillor R. O’ Donoghue

The amendment was ruled OUT OF ORDER.

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:             Twenty (20) 

Against:       Sixteen (16) 

Abstain:        One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:?Mahony, Mulligan, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, O’Brien, Kitt, Manton, O’Leary, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Henchy, Onwumereh, Dennehy, O’Donoghue, Leddy.

?Against:        Councillors:? Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Power, Ó Rodaigh, McCamley, Shovlin, Lavin, Boland, Healy, Conroy, Butler, McDonagh, Humphreys, Dennison.

Abstain:        Councillors:   Rane

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the Motion PASSED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor J. Guerin was WITHDRAWN.

Councillor B. Dennehy declared a conflict of interest with this Item due to a relationship by marriage to the landowner and withdrew from the Chamber.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, was proposed by Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, seconded by Councillor B. McDonagh:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

An amendment was proposed by Councillor R. O’ Donoghue, seconded by Councillor B. McDonagh to:

Amend the map as below: 

The amendment was AGREED.

SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS

Following discussion it was agreed by the Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony and the Members to suspend the meeting for 3 minutes.

On resumption of the meeting the Amended Motion was Put and on a division the voting resulted as follows:

For:             Sixteen (16) 

Against:       Twenty (20) 

Abstain:        One (1)

? 

For:                Councillors:?Mulligan, Donnelly, Hanaphy, Graves, Treacy, Maguire, Murphy, O’Brien, Manton, Lavin, Doyle, Newman, Guerin, Boland, Henchy, O’Donoghue.

?Against:        Councillors:? Mahony, Hopkins, Mulville, Whooley, Carey, Power, Kitt, Ó Rodaigh, Walsh, McCamley, Shovlin, Healy, Conroy, Butler, Onwumereh, McDonagh, Humphreys, Dennison, Leddy, Rane.

Abstain:        Councillors:   O’Leary

The Mayor, Councillor H. Mahony, declared the amended Motion LOST.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED, and following a discussion, the Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor D. Butler:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.

Minute Number FDP2/459/22 REFERS.

Minute Number FDP2/459/22 REFERS.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED, based on the premis that it will be subsumed into the Traffic Management Plan for Rush.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED, based on the premis that it will be subsumed into the Traffic Management Plan for Rush.

The attached motion in the name of Councillor B. Dennehy, was proposed by Councillor B. Dennehy, seconded by Councillor A. Henchy:

The attached report by the Chief Executive which had been circulated was CONSIDERED:

The Chief Executive’s recommendation was AGREED.